Snipe Class Rules update

by Gus Wirth, Technical Committee Chairman

The Snipe class rules for 2023 have been approved by World Sailing and become effective 1 July 2023. A large portion of the rules have been rewritten to adhere to World Sailing format but don’t actually have any practical effect on what we have already been using.

However, there are several changes that were submitted and approved by the Board of Governors for incorporation into the rules that require some explanation, the most controversial of which is Rule F.6.3(a) Shroud Adjusters.

The operation of shroud adjusters is regulated by rule C.9.6(a) which states:

C.9.6 CONDITIONS FOR USE, STANDING RIGGING

(a) The length of the shrouds and the forestay shall not be adjusted while racing.

The interpretation of this includes shroud adjusters. This rule has been in effect for a long time. So if someone were to adjust their shrouds while racing, it would be cheating.

Rule F.6.3 SHROUDS,  Rule F.6.3(a) states:

Any shroud adjusters that do not allow the manual adjustment of the shrouds with the rig under tension.

The meaning being you can not use shroud adjusters that can be operated under tension.

The problem with this rule is that there is no objective test criteria to evaluate operability. Such a test would require a definition of required tension, tool use or no tools, and conditions of use. It would also require a test program to evaluate parts. As such, this rule should be considered unenforceable until further notice.

An example of a problematic shroud adjuster is the QRT Toggle Terminal by Blue Wave. It looks like it might violate this rule based on its appearance with the built in handle. But in a statement directly from the manufacturer:

“If you adjust the QRT turnbuckles under high load you risk either to damage/twist the handle in a way that it can’t be locked into position, and secondly, possible galling of the threads.”

Breaking your boat because of cheating is never a good idea.

Based on this information, with no other criteria, these QRT shroud adjusters would be permitted.

The Sta-Master(TM) shroud adjusters would also be permitted due to their decades long use and practical experience.

Respectfully,

Gus Wirth

SCIRA Rules Committee Chairman

Share

1 comment

Jorn Haga
07/06/2023 -

Adjusting the tension on leeward side is no problem, since it is hardly ever under much tension, and thus can easily be adjusted, while racing

Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published. Your comment will be revised by the site if needed.

Jose Pérez Morales
08/18/2023 -

Jorn tiene toda la razón, es un gran experto, cualquier ajustador de tensión puede ser manipulado en el lado de sotavento. Creo que debemos pensar si realmente esta regla es necesaria. Todos los que estamos implicados en las regatas sabemos que son muchos los que cada día incumplen esta regla modificando la tensión de los obenques en regata... y va a seguir siendo así ya que el medidor no puede vigilar a todos y tampoco tiene que actuar de "policía". Cuando se creo esta regla los obenque se amarraban con piola o cordelillo y también el estay hasta no hace muchos años, pero los tiempos cambian y nuestra clase debe modernizarse y hacerse mas atractiva para esos jóvenes que necesitamos atraer... yo recuerdo cuando la driza del foque se fijaba en una posición para toda la regata. Los QRT de Blue Wave. son suficientemente seguros para modificar sobre todo sin tensión o solo con la adecuada. Es responsabilidad de la tripulación poner o NO topes en las crucetas o dar excesiva tensión a la driza... que puede así -exagerando-llegar a doblar o romper el palo... o tira demasiado fuerte de la trapa... Estoy absolutamente convencido que que esta regla debe ser eliminada, era la segunda opción de Luis Soubie' en su propuesta que el no quiso presentar

Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published. Your comment will be revised by the site if needed.

Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published. Your comment will be revised by the site if needed.